Opinion: New Bill May Make Aiding Migrants A Crime In Hungary

  • 6 Jun 2018 6:17 PM
Opinion: New Bill May Make Aiding Migrants A Crime In Hungary
A revised draft bill published by the Hungarian government on May 29, 2018, would criminalize efforts to help migrants and asylum seekers and curb their access to protection, says Human Rights Watch.

The bill the government presented to parliament proposes amending nine existing laws related to asylum, the national border, and the police.

It creates a new criminal offense in the Criminal Code of “enabling illegal immigration,” which is defined to include helping asylum seekers who are “not eligible for protection,” as well as to include border monitoring, producing and disseminating information, or “network building.”

If committed “regularly,” or with the aim of “help[ing] several persons,” the offense would be considered aggravated. Anyone convicted would face a sentence of up to a year in prison.

“This bill is the latest salvo in the Hungarian government’s war on refugees and those who help them,” said Benjamin Ward, deputy Europe and Central Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “Hungary’s government should withdraw this draft bill, honor the country’s duty to refugees, and end its odious campaign against rights defenders.”

The draft law would curb the right to asylum by introducing new admissibility criteria that would bar most asylum seekers from getting protection in Hungary.

It would allow the authorities to declare asylum applications from people arriving through a country other than their own inadmissible, unless the person could show that they were facing a serious risk of abuse or that the other country did not provide “adequate levels of protection.”

The burden of proof would be on the applicant, who would be unlikely to be able to substantiate such a claim without necessary access to information and support, and within the bill’s tight three-day deadline.

These new admissibility criteria could pave the way for a zero-protection system even for applicants fleeing mass human rights violations and generalized violence in Syria, Somalia, or Afghanistan, Human Rights Watch said.

Some of the problematic elements in an earlier version of the bill published in February have been removed from the new version, including describing assistance to asylum seekers and migrants as a threat to national security.

Earlier versions also gave the interior minister wide discretion to select organizations the minister favored to work with migrants. But by criminalizing working with asylum seekers and migrants, the new version is arguably more problematic, Human Rights Watch said.

The Hungarian government has cracked down on independent groups reporting on human rights issues, including the abuses migrants and asylum seekers face at Hungary’s borders.

There are serious concerns that the criminal offense is being introduced as another tool to silence these groups and to prevent victims of human rights violations from being able to reach out to anyone to document the abuses or help them seek redress. People working for the few groups still able to provide essential services, such as legal counselling or providing information about migrants’ rights and responsibilities, could face criminal prosecution.

While the rationale of the new law is that these measures are necessary to fight “illegal immigration,” the bill punishes activities that are legitimate and necessary, especially in a country whose government is systematically dismantling its asylum system. Hungary’s current migration and asylum laws and policies already breach European Union law and international refugee and human rights law.

The draft bill would also give the police the authority to bar anyone suspected of “enabling illegal immigration” from the border areas. This could lead to effectively banning anyone from the areas where migrants and asylum seekers are subjected to abuse at the hands of Hungarian authorities, including Human Rights Watch researchers, and staff from international agencies.

The United Nations refugee agency, UNHCR, has already called on the Hungarian government to withdraw the bill.

Simultaneously, the government has also submitted a proposal to amend the country’s constitution, banning the “settlement of foreign populations” in the country without specific, individualized permission by a national authority. This measure is likely to result in Hungary’s continuous veto against any relocation and resettlement schemes within the European Union.

The proposed Seventh Amendment to the Fundamental Law would also specify that people arriving to Hungary through a “safe third country” will not be eligible for refugee protection.

The constitutional amendment would also undermine the ability of the judiciary to review the new laws by specifying that judges should primarily use the legislator’s official reasoning when interpreting the law. The provision would undermine meaningful constitutional review, Human Rights Watch said.

“Governments have a responsibility to secure their borders, but the true purpose of Hungary’s proposed changes is to silence critics, remove its abuses against migrants from oversight and accountability, and evade the country’s responsibility to refugees,” Ward said.

“The European Commission needs to activate Article 7 of the European Union treaty, which is designed to deal with governments that put the Union’s values at risk.”

For more Human Rights Watch reporting on Hungary visit:

  • How does this content make you feel?

Explore More Reports

  • Fidesz: European Court Wants To Keep Criminals In Hungary

    Fidesz: European Court Wants To Keep Criminals In Hungary

    • 19 Sep 2018 8:59 AM

    The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) wants to keep criminals in Hungary instead of expelling them, ruling Fidesz said in reaction to a recent CJEU ruling concerning Shajin Ahmed, an Afghan national who had obtained refugee status in Hungary.

  • Szijjártó: OHCHR Attacks Hungary Over Illegal Migration

    Szijjártó: OHCHR Attacks Hungary Over Illegal Migration

    • 12 Sep 2018 9:09 AM

    The Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) is doing the same thing as Dutch green MEP Judith Sargentini and other pro-migration politicians: they attack Hungary because it does not let illegal migrants enter its territory, Foreign Minister Péter Szijjártó said.

  • Opinion: Hungary Is A Major Political And Economic Player In Montenegro

    Opinion: Hungary Is A Major Political And Economic Player In Montenegro

    • 23 Jul 2018 8:57 AM

    Donald Trump comes out with something outrageous practically every day. Take, for instance, his remarks on Montenegro. In an interview with Tucker Carlson of Fox News he made the following brilliant observation: “Montenegro is a tiny country with very strong people…. They’re very aggressive people. They may get aggressive, and congratulations, you’re in a world war three.”