Local Opinion: French Ambassador Replaced After Pro-Orbán Memo

  • 18 Jul 2018 9:14 AM
  • BudaPost
Local Opinion: French Ambassador Replaced After Pro-Orbán Memo
A conservative author thinks the French Foreign Ministry harmed itself by leaking a confidential note in which its ambassador to Budapest suggested a shift in France’s attitude toward the Hungarian Prime Minister.

In a confidential memo to his superiors in Paris, Ambassador Eric Fournier described Prime Minister Orbán as a proper conservative caught in the crosshairs of the international media, a target in a wave of ‘Hungarophobia’.

Hungary, he wrote, is a model in dealing with illegal migrants, and accusations of populism against Orbán were media fabrications.

Fournier also wrote that French media, by accusing Hungary of antisemitism, were distracting attention from the ’real antisemitism’ among Muslims in France and Germany.

He suggested that France should strike a more positive tone when speaking about and to the Hungarian leader.

When the memo was
leaked to the Mediapart news site, Fournier was replaced by President Macron and guests were received at the traditional garden party at his Budapest residence on July 14 (the anniversary of the 1789 revolution) by his successor who was promptly dispatched to Budapest but had not had the time to receive his accreditation by the Hungarian Foreign Ministry.

On Válasz, Gergely Pröhle sees the leak of a confidential note as an unprecedented incident in the history of legendary French diplomacy. He doesn’t take sides in the debate over Hungary’s migration policies or whether the replaced ambassador was right or wrong. His point is that discretion is elementary and indispensable in diplomacy.

Pröhle (who served as Hungary’s ambassador to Berlin and then to Switzerland before spending a decade as a State Secretary in the Foreign Ministry) explains that foreigners will find it difficult to talk in all sincerity to French diplomats if they cannot be sure that what the Ambassador reports to the Quai d’Orsay (The French Foreign Ministry) will be kept confidential.

He recalls that such doubts surfaced eight years ago when US diplomatic cables were posted on the Web by Wikileaks. But that time at least, it was not a deliberate leak by the State Department. Unlike this time. The French Foreign Office, Pröhle concludes, ‘has shot itself in the foot’.

This opinion does not necessarily represent the views of XpatLoop.com or the publisher. Your opinions are welcome too - for editorial review before possible publication online Click here to Share Your Story 

Photo: French Embassy's FB page

  • How does this content make you feel?

XpatLoop Media Partner


Launched in May 2011 to provide a balanced picture of matters covered in Hungary’s national press. Their aim is to make it easier for English-speakers to understand where this country is now and where it’s heading according to the full spectrum of media opinions.

Explore More Reports

  • Local Opinion: European Parliament Vote Still Dominates News

    Local Opinion: European Parliament Vote Still Dominates News

    • 19 Sep 2018 8:42 AM

    A pro-government economist describes the European Parliament vote against Hungary as an attack by global liberal elites on Hungary and national sovereignty. A left-wing commentator believes that the EU wants to defend Hungarian national interests and democracy from the attack they are under from the government.

  • Local Opinion: European Parliament Vote Opens A New Age

    Local Opinion: European Parliament Vote Opens A New Age

    • 18 Sep 2018 8:00 AM

    Commentators are sharply divided in their assessments of the clash between Hungary’s Prime Minister and his critics in the European Parliament. They agree however that what happened has opened a new chapter in the relations between Hungary and the European Union.

  • Opposition Parties Blast Orbán’s Speech

    Opposition Parties Blast Orbán’s Speech

    • 18 Sep 2018 7:57 AM

    Group leaders of Hungary’s opposition parties slammed Prime Minister Viktor Orbán’s speech opening the autumn session of parliament, accusing him of misrepresenting the Sargentini report approved in the European Parliament last week and of ignoring Hungary’s real problems.

  • Orbán European Parliament Has Pro-Migrant Majority For Now

    Orbán European Parliament Has Pro-Migrant Majority For Now

    • 14 Sep 2018 4:53 PM

    Noting that Europe would hold elections next May, Prime Minister Viktor Orbán called the current members of the European Parliament has-beens. The current EP has a “clear pro-migrant” majority whose mission “is to change the composition of the continent and replace its population”, Orbán said. He said certain EP politicians “hate all those who oppose their plans and organise resistance”.