Local Opinion: Dispute Over Gender Studies

  • 13 Aug 2018 8:10 AM
  • BudaPost
Local Opinion: Dispute Over Gender Studies
As the government proposes to cancel the accreditation of gender studies university degree programs, left-wing and liberal pundits accuse the government of ideology driven interference in higher education. Conservative commentators are divided on the proposed ban.

On Thursday, the Ministry of Human Resources circulated a draft decree that would withdraw the accreditation of gender studies MA programs. Universities were given 24 hours to comment the draft.

Gender studies programs are currently offered by two universities, ELTE and CEU. The Ministry of Human Resources said that gender studies education is economically not justified, and there is no public need for it anyways.

The ELTE has announced that it accepts the ministry’s decision and comply with the new regulation. Government politicians have claimed in the past that gender studies should be regarded as ideological indoctrination rather than meaningful university education, and its core doctrines are contrary to the government’s values.

In Heti Világgazdaság, Dávid Dercsényi accuses the government of shutting down gender studies for ideologically reasons.

The left-wing liberal columnist contends that the move is motivated by the  government’s drive to express its commitment to traditional Christian values and underscore its anti-multiculturalism and anti-immigration stance. Dercsényi speculates that the government would also ban abortions in the name of Chrstian values if it did not fear public uproar.

On 24.hu, Attila Kálmán interprets the draft decree as a weapon in the government’s cultural warfare. By vilifying gender studies and feminism, he suggests, the government is creating an imaginary enemy against whom it can claim to defend Hungarians from disruptive Western progressive ideologies.

The left-wing commentator characterizes this strategy as a common feature of populist right-wing parties.

“I hope all this is fake news,” Gábor Bencsik comments the draft decree on Facebook. The conservative pundit believes that it is scholarly relevant and socially important to study the role of biological sex in society.

Without learning the implications of gender, it is not possible to boost the birth rate and restore family love. Bencsik admits that some gender studies departments follow radical feminist and extreme liberal ideologies, thinks nonetheless that most gender studies departments are valuable. He calls on Christian conservative intellectuals to ‘protect the government from an ill-advised decision’.

Pesti Srácok’s Tamás Pilhál welcomes the government’s plan to ‘sweep universities clear of gender-agitators”.

The pro-government blogger thinks that gender studies should not have been accredited in the first place. Pilhál disagrees with Bencsik and likens gender studies departments to ‘Satanist sects’, noting that gender studies are unlikely to help us ‘regain our reproductive capacity’.

He adds that gender studies is a ‘fashionable Western stupidity’. Citing gender studies scholars, Pilhál notes that gender studies education does indeed try to facilitate the social acceptance and toleration of homosexuality and even of sex reassignment procedures.

168 Óra’s Győző Mátyás finds the suggestion that gender studies want to advance transsexual norms absurd. The left-wing columnist contends that gender studies is the scientific investigation of the construction of gender roles in society.

Mátyás, however, acknowledges that some contemporary radical feminists activists including Andrea Dworkin and Judith/Jack Halberstam advocate ‘hair-raising’ ideas and use gender studies for ‘dogmatic’ political purposes. Mátyás thinks nonetheless that strong open societies can tolerate the discussion of such ideas, and only authoritarian regimes want to ban them.

In a Facebook comment, András Stumpf finds the government’s plan to ban gender studies nauseating.

The conservative pundit finds transgender identities ridiculous, and describes the suggestion that biological sex is fully socially constructed as an absurd proposition. Nevertheless, he warns against what he calls a ‘Bolshevik tradition’ of infringment with institutional freedom in education.

Fruzsina Skrabski agrees with the government that culture and science are dominated by a liberal minority ideology. But the conservative columnist also finds it undesirable for the government to change liberal hegemony through decrees. Instead, Skrabski calls for an open discussion between conservative demography scholars and gender studies professors.

This opinion does not necessarily represent the views of XpatLoop.com or the publisher. Your opinions are welcome too - for editorial review before possible publication online Click here to Share Your Story 

  • How does this content make you feel?

XpatLoop Media Partner

BudaPost

Launched in May 2011 to provide a balanced picture of matters covered in Hungary’s national press. Their aim is to make it easier for English-speakers to understand where this country is now and where it’s heading according to the full spectrum of media opinions.

Explore More Reports

  • Local Opinion: Viktor Orbán’s “Enormous Victory” In Salzburg?

    Local Opinion: Viktor Orbán’s “Enormous Victory” In Salzburg?

    • 21 Sep 2018 7:47 AM

    The Hungarian public still knows practically nothing about what went on at the informal summit of the European Council in Salzburg. The little information that reached Budapest came from Antal Rogán, who had a telephone conversation with MTI, Hungary’s news service.

  • Local Opinion: European Parliament Vote Still Dominates News

    Local Opinion: European Parliament Vote Still Dominates News

    • 19 Sep 2018 8:42 AM

    A pro-government economist describes the European Parliament vote against Hungary as an attack by global liberal elites on Hungary and national sovereignty. A left-wing commentator believes that the EU wants to defend Hungarian national interests and democracy from the attack they are under from the government.

  • Local Opinion: European Parliament Vote Opens A New Age

    Local Opinion: European Parliament Vote Opens A New Age

    • 18 Sep 2018 8:00 AM

    Commentators are sharply divided in their assessments of the clash between Hungary’s Prime Minister and his critics in the European Parliament. They agree however that what happened has opened a new chapter in the relations between Hungary and the European Union.