EP Draft Report Criticises Rule Of Law In Hungary

  • 13 Apr 2018 9:43 AM
  • Hungary Matters
EP Draft Report Criticises Rule Of Law In Hungary
Presenting the draft report in a session of the European Parliament committee in Brussels, Green MEP Judith Sargentini said there was a “clear risk of a serious breach by Hungary of the values of the European Union”, which she said warranted launching the Article 7 procedure.

Sargentini said the Hungarian government had curbed the powers of Hungary’s Constitutional Court and judicial independence and launched attacks against civil society. She added that the state of press freedom and freedom of expression had also deteriorated.

She said the report was not about the situation of asylum seekers in Hungary but rather about the fundamental rights of Hungarians and how the state treats its own citizens. Given the situation in Hungary, the EU has a duty to act, she added. “The time for warnings has passed.”

Roberta Metsola of the European People’s Party (EPP) said the report was not aimed as an attack against Hungary, saying that it would be wrong to “try to draw political capital” from it.

She added, at the same time, that there were several points in the document that, in the EPP’s opinion, “would not ... seem to fit with the ultimate aim of this report”.

Social Democrat MEP Ana Gomes said the situation in Hungary was “worrying”, adding that it had deteriorated significantly over the past few years. “There is a systemic threat to democracy and the rule of law and fundamental rights in Hungary,” Gomes said.

She also highlighted minority rights, the right to the freedom of assembly, academic freedom, corruption and the rights of asylum seekers as problematic areas.

Marek Jurek of the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR) group said the Hungarian government had been subjected to “baseless accusations”. “Every country has a right to protect its sovereignty,” he said, adding that Hungary “is only being attacked over its cultural differences”.

Liberal MEP Sophia in’t Veld said in reaction to Jurek that although cultural differences should be respected, so should the EU’s fundamental values.

She accused the Hungarian government of pursuing a “disgusting hate campaign” and said Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán posed a threat to the EU’s integrity. If Hungary were a candidate country today, it would not be admitted into the bloc, she insisted.

Fidesz MEP Kinga Gál said: “The reason why they’re smearing Hungary is because it won’t fall in line, but instead stands up to the mandatory resettlement of migrants.” She said the discussion about the situation in Hungary was “completely devoid of objectivity”.

Gál said the potential Article 7 procedure against Hungary “looks like a pre-arranged show trial that will end with a pre-determined political verdict”.

Socialist Party MEP István Ujhelyi said he was “deeply embarrassed” and regretted that “Hungarian politics has put the country into this situation here in front of our European community and European allies”.

Independent Hungarian MEP Krisztina Morvai, formerly a member of the radical nationalist Jobbik party, said the “attacks” against Hungary had united the country against “impertinence”. Hungary’s recent election showed that whereas the country had been “hugely outnumbered, it managed to defeat the will of the EU and [US financier George] Soros’s armies”, she said.

Balázs Hidvéghi, ruling Fidesz’s communications director, branded the draft document as the “Soros report”, saying it was a “frontal attack” against Hungary and “another obvious attempt to pressure Hungary into taking in migrants”.

“We’re barely done with the election and Soros’s people in Brussels have already launched a frontal attack against Hungary in the European Parliament,

 Hidvéghi told public media. “The Soros empire’s representatives in Brussels are ignoring the decision made by the people and ignoring the outcome of Hungary’s democratic elections; they are angry and aggressively threatening to cut Hungary’s funding and suspend its voting rights.”

Hidvéghi said this was “unacceptable”, adding that the Fideszled government would continue to do everything in its power to protect Hungary from immigration.

“We won’t give in on this issue and we’ll continue to fight against pressure from Brussels,” he said. Public opinion on migration in Europe, he added, was shifting and the number of Hungary’s political allies was also growing.

MEPs have until May 15 to submit amendment proposals to the draft report. LIBE is expected to submit the document to the EP in June, which the legislative body is expected to vote on in the autumn.

  • How does this content make you feel?

XpatLoop Media Partner

Hungary Matters

Launched in January 2014, this twice-daily newsletter covers 'everything you need to know about what’s going on in Hungary and beyond', according to its publisher the state media agency MTI. Click the title above for more info, and to subscribe.

Explore More Reports

  • Trump & PM Orbán To Cut Billion-Dollar Arms Deals

    Trump & PM Orbán To Cut Billion-Dollar Arms Deals

    • 13 May 2019 9:27 AM

    The meeting of Prime Minister Viktor Orban and President Donald Trump in the White House on May 13 will not only be a breakthrough in U.S.-Hungarian relations, but it could also bring significant changes to Hungary’s military reports direkt36.hu.

  • Hungarian Opinion: Analyses Ahead Of Trump - Orbán Summit

    Hungarian Opinion: Analyses Ahead Of Trump - Orbán Summit

    • 8 May 2019 6:49 AM

    A left-wing columnist thinks President Trump intends to express concern over Hungary’s co-operation with China and Russia, while pro-government commentators suggest that he wants to bolster Mr. Orbán’s position before the European Elections.